Skip to main content

We’ve Been Measuring Identity at the Wrong Speed

Blog
Fraud
Account Takeover
Promotion Abuse
Identity Analytics
Data analysis
Fraud prevention innovation
Diarmuid Thoma, Head of Fraud & Data Strategy, AtData
Dec 02, 2026
Blog

Everyone’s talking about identity accuracy, but what about identity velocity?

Trust has a half-life.

Not necessarily because the information behind it turns inaccurate, but because the world around it keeps moving.

Risk teams make decisions using signals collected at different points in time, often without a clear understanding of how quickly those signals lose relevance. Some grow more valuable as they accumulate history, while others age the moment they’re collected. Understanding which is which may be more important than the signals themselves.

The hardest identity decisions aren’t about the unknown. They’re about the familiar.

An email address that’s been associated with legitimate activity for years feels easier to trust than one you’ve never seen before. Most of the time, that’s safe to assume. But trust isn’t static. The same identity that was low risk six months ago, six weeks ago, or even yesterday may deserve a very different assessment today.

We’ve become accustomed to measuring identity by its accuracy. Perhaps it’s time to pay closer attention to its half-life.

The Shelf Life of a Trust Signal

The concept of half-life comes from physics, where it describes the time required for a quantity to decrease by half. Applied to identity, it’s an interesting way to think about data relevance. How long does a piece of information remain useful in decision-making? When does its predictive value diminish? And what happens when something we considered reliable stops reflecting current reality?

The truth is, there isn’t a universal expiration date. An email address that’s been active for ten years can carry considerable historical value. Its longevity, activity, and established associations offer a different level of context than an address with virtually no history. Yet even a longstanding identity can be compromised or repurposed.

That’s part of the challenge of identity risk: working across two points in time. The data being used may have been collected months ago, while the behavior being assessed is happening right now. Between those points, circumstances can change, turning previously reliable information into a misleading signal.

For businesses, the consequences show up in familiar places: an account starts behaving differently, promotional offers get exploited, or a returning customer whose activity triggers the same risk controls as someone with no established history. In each case, the underlying data may be accurate and fully validated. But the decision is being made in the present using signals rooted in the past, and when circumstances change, even good data can point to the wrong conclusion.

Email Anchors Identity Across Time

Much of the infrastructure surrounding digital commerce has become transient: cookies expire, device identifiers fragment, and consumers move fluidly across platforms and accounts. But we still need a way to understand whether the person showing up today is connected to the customer we met yesterday.

Email occupies a unique position in the identity ecosystem because it can connect years of activity, acting as a continuous thread through identity systems that are otherwise fragmented by changing devices, channels, and platforms.

And this continuity creates something invaluable today: context. What makes email interesting isn’t just its longevity, but its ability to compare who an identity appeared to be yesterday with who it appears to be today. The address acts as a thread connecting multiple points in time, making it possible to spot both continuity and change.

But continuity isn’t the same as certainty. An email address with a decade of history can still be compromised. Likewise, a trusted customer can experience account takeover and a profile that once represented legitimate behavior can suddenly exhibit risk. The historical record might be accurate, but the reality behind it can still change.

This is why moving faster doesn’t necessarily improve decision-making. A risk system can process information in milliseconds and still arrive at the wrong conclusion if it lacks the context needed to interpret what it’s seeing. The question isn’t simply whether an email address is valid. It’s whether the identity behind it still looks like the same identity that built years of trust in the first place.

And as fraud grows more automated and convincing, businesses are increasingly being asked to distinguish legitimate customers from imitators in fractions of a second. A single signal rarely gives enough information to support that kind of judgment. What matters is the ability to understand both continuity and change.

Email address intelligence helps with context—it provides a baseline. Without one, every interaction must be judged on its own. With one, businesses can see whether today’s activity looks consistent with what they’ve come to expect from that identity or whether something seems different.

Trust Doesn’t Stand Still

Perhaps the next big move in identity risk management will have less to do with collecting more information and more to do with understanding the lifespan of what we already have.

Some identity signals grow more useful over time. Others need more reassessment. The challenge is knowing which is which. And this influences how loyalty programs are protected, how accounts are evaluated, how promotional abuse is identified, and how legitimate customers move through the buying experience.

An accurate piece of information isn’t automatically a timely one, and a history of legitimate activity shouldn’t make an identity immune to future scrutiny.

Trust is built over time. Maintaining it requires paying attention to what happens next.

Trust doesn’t stand still, and neither should your identity strategy.
See how AtData evaluates identity using both historical context and current signals so businesses make more confident fraud, risk, and customer experience decisions.


AtData logo

About AtData

AtData helps organizations connect with real people, prevent fraud, and improve digital trust through permissioned, email-anchored identity intelligence and the largest network of activity signals. With more than 25 years of experience in data quality, identity, and fraud prevention, AtData supports enterprises across marketing, risk, and data operations.

 

Diarmuid Thoma

About the author

Diarmuid Thoma is Head of Fraud & Data Strategy with AtData, an Experian company, where he leads the development of enterprise fraud models and the productization of email-based intelligence to reduce risk and preserve revenue. Over a career spanning more than two decades, he has designed fraud prevention programs for major technology and security firms, including Facebook, Symantec, Hewlett-Packard and TransUnion. His in-depth knowledge of the global fraud prevention market and its context within regional compliance has accelerated AtData’s solutions. He is a regular industry speaker on topics including email intelligence, the application of digital trust signals, and balancing fraud controls with customer experience.

Blue-tinted background of a man watching a webinar

Host a Webinar with the MRC

Help the MRC community stay current on relevant fraud, payments, and law enforcement topics.
Submit a Request

Publish Your Document with the MRC

Feature your case studies, surveys, and whitepapers in the MRC Resource Center.
Submit Your Document

Related Resources